The Amazon Conundrum: A Promising Behemoth at a Crossroads

Written By Michael Gary Scott

Amazon has been the golden child of the stock market, with its (NASDAQ: AMZN) shares delivering mind-blowing returns over the past decade. The 975% surge in stock price vastly outshining the S&P 500‘s 167% growth has left investors drooling over their portfolios.

However, basking in past glories is a dangerous game in the volatile world of stocks. To discern whether Amazon’s shares are a buy, sell, or hold, one needs to delve into a fundamental analysis of its prospects.

While the enchanting allure of Amazon’s flourishing stock performance lingers, the crystal ball of future growth remains clouded. Conducting an in-depth evaluation of Amazon’s potential is critical for any prudent investor.

Someone standing and holding a shipping box while looking down toward a laptop.

Image source: Getty Images.

Clouds on the Horizon: Amazon Web Services

Amazon’s crown jewel, Amazon Web Services (AWS), has reigned supreme in the cloud-computing sphere with its rapid expansion and hefty profit margins.

However, cracks in the facade are beginning to show as the growth rate of AWS sales decelerates. Despite a respectable 13% surge in fourth-quarter sales to $24.2 billion, the golden days of 28% year-over-year revenue growth have dwindled.

Although AWS still boasts the highest profit margin among Amazon’s segments, the slight dip in its market share from 33% to 31% hints at intensifying competition from the likes of Microsoft’s Azure and Alphabet.

The E-commerce Juggernaut

Amazon’s e-commerce prowess is renowned, capturing the hearts of online shoppers worldwide. As the e-commerce sector’s share of total Q4 retail sales in the U.S. climbed to 15.6%, Amazon stands at the frontline of this retail revolution.

Despite its dominance in online retail, physical stores, and the burgeoning advertising business, Amazon’s North American and international segments struggle to translate robust sales growth into substantial profits.

See also  The Nasdaq 100 Stocks to Consider in February 2024 The Nasdaq 100 Stocks to Consider in February 2024

The magnetic appeal of Amazon’s low prices and swift shipping is undeniable, painting a rosy picture for its future in the e-commerce landscape.

Premium Dilemma: Valuation and Market Expectations

Amazon’s stock commands a premium over the broader market indices, with a current price-to-sales (P/S) ratio of 3.2 compared to the S&P 500’s 2.7. This premium valuation signals the market’s anticipation of Amazon’s profits skyrocketing in the near future.

In the short term, Amazon’s outlook appears solid, with management forecasting a sizeable surge in Q1 operating income. Yet, questions loom over the sustainability of this growth trajectory, especially concerning the sluggish momentum in AWS and the erosion of market share.

Considering Amazon’s entrenched position in e-commerce and the promising advertising sector, tempered by the challenges faced by AWS, a cautious approach to holding onto existing Amazon shares while avoiding fresh acquisitions seems prudent.

Navigating the Tavern of Decision: Investing in Amazon

Before plunging into the abyss of Amazon stock, a prudent investor must weigh the risks and rewards meticulously. While the lure of Amazon’s past successes may be alluring, grounding investment decisions in thorough research is paramount.

The Motley Fool Stock Advisor team has looked beyond Amazon and uncovered 10 stocks they believe hold greater promise for investors seeking monstrous returns in the coming years.

This voyage of discovery offers investors a roadmap to navigate the tumultuous seas of the stock market, providing expert guidance, regular updates, and two new stock picks monthly. A treasure trove of opportunities beckons beyond the shores of Amazon.

*Stock Advisor returns as of April 22, 2024