Welcome to Market Tangents

Exploring Tax Rates vs Tax Burdens

Understanding how income taxes are computed remains a complex puzzle for many Americans unversed in the nuances of tax laws and terminology. Terms like tax rate and tax burden can often be baffling.

A tax rate signifies the percentage at which an individual or business is levied, with considerable variations based on income levels. On the other hand, tax burden represents the total sum of taxes paid, encompassing state and local taxes. This distinction assumes a pronounced importance when contrasting the wealthiest and poorest 20% in every state.

Research Methodology Breakdown

To discern the disparities in tax burdens nationwide, GOBankingRates delved into state, federal, and local data to unravel the tax burdens of affluent and impoverished individuals for single filers and married joint filers in each state. Harnessing data from the U.S. Census Consumer Expenditure Survey and the Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Expenditure Survey, this comprehensive analysis employed an in-house income tax calculator to ascertain the effective and marginal tax rates on average incomes for both demographic segments in every state.

The study additionally scrutinized the annual expenditures in each state, multiplying them by the average combined sales tax to compute the total sales tax expenditure for each state. The cumulative sum expended on federal and state income taxes was added to the aggregate spent on sales tax and then divided by the average income. Notably, property tax was excluded from the analysis due to data inconsistencies.

Implications of Tax Disparity

The wealthiest 20% invariably bear a more substantial tax burden; however, despite this higher tax load, these individuals command significantly more wealth than the poorest quintile. Thus, each tax dollar exacts a heavier toll on the poorest 20%. For instance, in a scenario where a state’s tax burden for single filers stands at 27.50%, this does not signify that the wealthiest 20% pay 27.50% more than the poorest quintile. Instead, it signifies that they contribute 27.50% more of their personal income compared to the poorest 20%.

State-Specific Tax Burdens for Different Income Strata

Alabama

• Single Filing for Richest 20%:
  • Average Annual Income of Richest 20%: $213,012
  • Total Taxes Paid: $69,320
  • Tax Burden: 32.54%
• Single Filing for Poorest 20%:
  • Average Annual Income of Poorest 20%: $11,401
  • Total Taxes Paid: $1,252
  • Tax Burden: 10.98%

Difference in Tax Burden: 21.56%

• Married Filing Jointly for Richest 20%:
  • Average Annual Income of Richest 20%: $213,012
  • Total Taxes Paid: $57,825
  • Tax Burden: 27.15%
• Married Filing Jointly for Poorest 20%:
  • Average Annual Income of Poorest 20%: $11,401
  • Total Taxes Paid: $968
  • Tax Burden: 8.49%

Difference in Tax Burden: 18.65%

Alaska

• Single Filing for Richest 20%:
  • Average Annual Income of Richest 20%: $254,899
  • Total Taxes Paid: $75,761
  • Tax Burden: 29.72%
• Single Filing for Poorest 20%:
  • Average Annual Income of Poorest 20%: $20,172
  • Total Taxes Paid: $2,175
  • Tax Burden: 10.78%

Difference in Tax Burden: 18.94%

• Married Filing Jointly for Richest 20%:
  • Average Annual Income of Richest 20%: $254,899
  • Total Taxes Paid: $60,828
  • Tax Burden: 23.86%
• Married Filing Jointly for Poorest 20%:
  • Average Annual Income of Poorest 20%: $20,172
  • Total Taxes Paid: $1,543
  • Tax Burden: 7.65%

Difference in Tax Burden: 16.21%